Monday, August 27, 2012

The NFL Eightfold Path: AFC North



The AFC North review carries a different tone than most of the divisions we have covered. The two perennially elite teams have taken huge hits that suggest at least a minor regression this season. In Pittsburgh, the injuries are already piling up and picking up from where last season left off. Mendenhall, Redman, Harrison, Hampton, DeCastro, and Roethlisberger all enter the season at under 100% healthy. Even if nothing else goes wrong, this will be a tough season for them. The terrible offensive line play shows little hope for improvement and new offensive coordinator Todd Haley’s system may not get a fair chance because of it. In Baltimore, the defensive player of the year has been lost for the entire season (Terrell Suggs). Ray Lewis and Ed Reed are both one year older and are dangerously close to the end of their careers. Offensively, there is not much hope outside of Ray Rice and maybe the emergence of Torrey Smith. Joe Flacco depends on factors that are currently weakening before him. The biggest question is where the Bengals finish against two vulnerable veterans of the AFC North. The Browns are still worlds behind, but there is plenty up in the air between three major playoff contenders.

4. Browns: There is not much to analyze about a team among the NFL’s worst struggling to compete alongside some of the NFL’s best. Because of the comparative weakness of this conference as a whole, the next three teams are all actually legitimate Super Bowl contenders. Cleveland, on the other hand, has been in a rebuilding phase for as long as I can remember. Maybe Brandon Weeden is the answer at quarterback, Trent Richardson can be a beast that carries the offense, and Josh Cribbs finally establishes some consistency alongside his big play ability. However, even with these issues successfully addressed, the Browns do not have enough to compete with and eventually win this division. Maybe once the great Steelers and Ravens all retire they can make a run for it against Cincinnati, but Cleveland’s championship breakthrough does not look like it will come in the NFL, or anywhere for that matter.

3. Bengals: I cannot pretend to be sure about the order of the three quality teams in this division. The only reason I do not have the Bengals higher, despite the previously stated flaws of the remaining two teams, is because I just do not feel they have enough to make that leap forward. Andy Dalton, for whatever reason, seems more vulnerable to the classic sophomore slump than Cam Newton. Benjarvus Green-Ellis is a nice runner to have, but has never really been relied on as the primary source of offense. Despite Dalton and star receiver AJ Green’s production last season, the Bengals’ mindset was always run first. Coming from New England, I have not seen enough from Green-Ellis to trust that he can take that kind of workload. We may finally see his first professional fumble this year, along with a few struggles that come with being a true work horse like injuries or fatigue. If the offense responds to this by shifting to a more pass heavy system, my sophomore slump prediction then comes into play. With more responsibility and only Jermaine Gresham as a quality target to throw to once Green is double covered, Dalton may have more trouble this season. Their defense is healthy and capable but not elite or great enough to compare to even a limping defense from Baltimore or Pittsburgh.

2. Steelers: The tough playoff loss for my Steelers was an excellent preview of what things may be like in Pittsburgh throughout 2012-13. Injuries and age have hit this team harder than any other in football and somehow, they have yet to fully pay the price for it. Last season carried similar criticisms, especially for Dick LeBeau’s defensive unit, which somehow ended the season as the NFL’s number one defense. The Steelers, more than any other team, are defined by their system. Take their careless attitude towards losing talented players as a great example of how they do business. Plaxico Burress and Santonio Holmes were both arguably top ten receivers at the time of their Pittsburgh departure. Despite tough losses on the roster, they always come back just as good if not better than before. The Steelers are going through an interesting transitional phase with Todd Haley now calling the shots on offense, but I trust his system. Pittsburgh does not rebuild, they reload. So long as Big Ben is on offense and Troy Polamalu is on defense, the surrounding pieces will work something out well enough to maintain this team’s identity. The reason I cannot give my team the division title this season is mistakes. We are arguably the most mistake prone team in the NFL because our quarterback would rather die than admit defeat. Ben gets himself in way too much trouble by holding onto the ball for too long, eventually getting sacked and possibly injured. This is also accompanied by many fumbles and ill-advised passes that become interceptions. Another cause of these miscues is the pitiful offensive line. If our defense is the Steel Curtain, the high school level offensive line is the Teflon Curtain. Roethlisberger can outplay Joe Flacco any day and I may even argue that our defense is still superior to Baltimore’s as well, but the unforgivable mistakes will eventually unravel and dismantle my favorite team.

1. Baltimore: In contrast to my last point about Pittsburgh, this Ravens team never seems to make any mistakes. They can be beat by a team that simply has more positives, but Baltimore commits next to zero negatives, which is a huge advantage. While they may not have as many strengths as their rivals, three things keep the Ravens from losing games. First of all, I may look down on Flacco’s ability as a quarterback but he does know how to not screw up. He traditionally does his job well enough for their others pieces to win him the game. The second reason, Ray Rice, is by far the division’s best playmaker. He can carry the Ravens’ offense, hold onto the ball, and consistently make things happen for them so their underwhelming passing game has plenty of leniency. The third factor that brings home this victory is their outstanding offensive line, which is among the league’s best. They prevent the pressure that causes offensive mistakes. While I do have faith in Roethlisberger, everything seems to be working against him and he may or may not survive any given game. Baltimore, however, plays mistake free football and can make enough plays to let a strong defensive effort win games for them. Even without the elite pass rush from Suggs, Lewis and Reed will keep that Ravens defense together and strong enough to win this powerful but limping division.

It seems odd to have no change in the order of last season’s AFC North standings after an offseason in which this division saw so much change. Despite the many moving pieces, I do not feel that any one team made significant enough strides to overtake another. The most likely leap frog would be Cinci taking the runner up spot away from Pittsburgh, but I am not buying Andy Dalton as much as most people are after his promising rookie year. What we may see is a similar order within the AFC North but the division as a whole will not stack up so well against AFC teams with rising stock like the Texans or Broncos. Because the North is traditionally the AFC’s best division, losing ground may only level the playing field. Teams in other divisions will work hard to limit them to only one playoff team this season. While I still believe two will make it, the Steelers and Ravens have a lot to worry about.

No comments:

Post a Comment